Into the shed out back,
I noticed a whole garden
On those thorny orbs so quickly,
The White Queen on the other side
Of Alice’s Looking Glass
Practiced believing impossible things -
As many as six -
Before breakfast.
I see the merit in such and approach.
It encourages imagination,
An, ironically, possibility.
But when I ponder it,
There is also merit
In believing as many as six
Possible things before breakfast.
When I think about the fact
That I wake up most mornings
Immersed in a sea of certainties
Flowing through my mind and all around me
So constantly
That I hardly know they are there,
It occurs to me that most other people wake up
In seas of similar certitude
But of different certainties.
The people I most disagree with,
The people who think things I could never think,
Thoughts that are not only wrong
But translate into horrible actions
And terrible policies
Are just as certain as I am
Of their rightness
Before they sit down to coffee and eggs and bacon.
So perhaps
It behoves me to think six possible things before breakfast.
Is it possible that I’m wrong?
Is it possible that my certainty is an idol
I bow down to so I don’t have to think?
Is it possible I’m a hypocrite?
Is it possible that when my certainties
Are brought out of my head
Into the light
They will make a scene and clash with each other?
That I might have a fight on my hands
Between rival ideas
That I thought got along fine
But actually want to tear each other’s throats out?
Do I hold others to a standard
I don’t expect of myself?
Is it possible that I’m
Just going with my gut,
My knee jerk reaction,
With what I want to be true,
When in reality,
If pressed,
I don’t actually know very much
About the opinions I’m so sure of?
Is it possible that the world
Of ideas that I take for granted
Is just a construction,
Like the movie Matrix,
But created by my own mind:
Made up of biases
And prejudices
And online filter bubbles
And money being made somewhere
Out there in the digital either
From the fact that I keep on clicking
On the things that already agree with me.
Is it possible that I have reduced
The world into simple binaries
(Ones and zeroes in computer parlance)
Without nuance,
Without color,
All black and white,
And myself always standing in the light
Of righteousness?
Is it possible I am missing the nuances,
The inbetween-ness of things
The allows for complexity,
For paradox?
Is it possible that
The worldview I find on my head each morning
Like an enormous hat
I have somehow slept in
Is a protective helmet
I have built around my mind
To keep out the thoughts
That might actually help me grow?
But will I actually
Question myself?
Will I attempt to step
Out of my comfortable,
Limited perspective?
Or is that impossible?
If so, perhaps I have thought six
Impossible things before breakfast
After all.
You prop up a straw man argument
when the real argument you are fighting against
is hard to defeat.
You replace their argument with your own version
a version that is a parody of the original argument
minus any wit
but bearing a strong scent of desperation,
a ripe odor like rotting vegetation.
You smirked
when they said
people will die
and answered,
We are all going to die.
You knew that none of them were ignorant of death.
But you pretended your opponents
were so stupid
that they actually didn’t know
humans are mortal.
You propped up your first straw man,
Who announced,
People live forever!
That’s a pretty easy argument
to knock down.
You doubled down when they objected,
standing in the tombstones
issuing a sneered apology
comparing their supposed ignorance of inevitable death
To belief in the Toothfairy.
Your second straw man:
Your opposition believes the Toothfairy is real.
A straw man blended with a non-sequiter.
But you weren’t done
Producing staw men.
You then invited people
To seek eternal life
By embracing your Lord and Savior,
Jesus Christ.
I suspect you are embracing
a straw man Jesus,
a misrepresentation
of the man recorded in the gospels.
I’ve seen a lot of versions of Jesus
put forth by many different people,
but nihilist Jesus is a new one.
I don’t recall Jesus
smirking at the lame and the leperous,
the blind and the bleeding,
and saying, Tough luck.
Can’t help you.
We are all going to die.
To say everyone is going to die
Is truth.
But context matters.
You were saying that because everyone is going to die,
we don’t need to care about them or heal them
or care about their quality of life
while they are here.
We just need to let them die.
Embracing eternal life,
we can ignore this one.
With every person Jesus met,
he showed concern,
not just for their souls,
but for their very earthy bodies as well.
for their health,
for their well-being,
physically and mentally.
This set of blind eyes.
This rotting flesh.
This bent back.
This set of motionless legs.
If you are concerned about the afterlife,
you might want to review the parable
of the sheep and the goats.
You know the part.
God separates the sheep from the goats
and tells the sheep they are inheriting
The Kingdom of God
Because they - among other things -
Took care of Jesus
When he was sick.
And they don’t recall doing that,
and Jesus tells them
That whatever they do for the least of these -
Like, for instance, caring for the sick -
you do it for me.
When you callously looked at that crowd
And said We are all going to die
You said it to Jesus.
Tough luck, Jesus,
I’m not helping you when you are sick.
You are going to die.
A straw man can be
Something you prop up
In place of your opponents’ real argument.
A straw man (or woman)
Can also be a front man
Used to cover up
Dirty dealings.
A straw man (or woman)
Can also be defined
As a person without substance
Or integrity.
It seems that in making
Straw men so often,
You have become one yourself.
Or maybe you were made of straw
To begin with
And straw simply creates more straw.
You sent your straw man argument
and your straw man Jesus
out to dance in front of a real argument.
the real argument is this:
we are supposed to care for
and take care of each other.
We aren’t supposed to treat each other
as being as disposable
as straw.
Avoid people who whip up your anger
At other people.
They are controlling you.
Don't listen to people
Who stoke up your fears,
Especially your fears of other people,
They are manipulating you.
Move away from people
Who tell you only they
Have got the truth
And that all those other people
Are liars.
They are lying.
Change channels on
Voices that agree with everything
You already think
And tell you exactly
What you want to hear.
They are playing you.
Plug your ears and go take a walk
When people get hyperbolic about
Your perceived enemies.
They are Nazi-Communist-cannibal-pedophilic-lying-theiving-human-excrement.
They are projecting.
Take a deep breath and go talk to someone different
From your normal crowd.
When they tell you to Other
Other people,
To label them, to write them off, to discard them,
To consider them un-people,
Write off what they are saying.
They are trying to make you less than human.
Run away from people
Who mainly value freedom
When it's the freedom
To badmouth others and mistreat them.
They love freedom if it means taking other people's freedom
To live in peace
Away from them.
Don't be a marrionette,
Jerked around by the strings of bias,
And hatred,
And fear.
When all you hear from a voice
Is what it is against,
Ask it what it's for.
Ask it:
When you take away fear,
Hate, resentment,
Enemy-creation, and negativity,
What is left?
What is the good.
And if they tell you those things are good,
Get as far away as you can.
They may be telling you their truth.
But that is not the same as
The
Truth.
But here's the hard part.
Try not to hate them either.
Don't dehumanize even the dehumanizers.
Unless you want to become the thing you hate.
The major villains get all the attention:
The Eye of Sauron,
Emperor Palpatine,
Voldemort,
Characters so irredeemably evil
They have little to teach us in their remote power
Because we feel we'll never be like them.
But consider the lesser villains:
Denethor,
Saruman and Dooku
(Both played by Christopher Lee)
And Lando Calrissian in betrayal mode in Empire
And all the toadies like Wormtail and Umbridge
Who throw in their lot with the Death Eaters.
What do they all have in common?
They have lost hope in goodness,
In right prevailing.
They think their only hope,
Such as it is,
Is in joining with the enemy,
Being realistic,
Throwing their lot in with the winning side.
But the Frodos, the Gandalfs, the Lukes, the Obi Wans,
The Harry Potters,
Of our tales
Never lose hope.
They don't cling to optimism.
They know they may lose,
That evil may triumph in the end.
But they never lose hope
Because though you cannot control ends,
Your own ability to aspire to right action
Means hope is in the action
Not in your mind.
To behave as though the right will win out in the end,
Even when you are certain it will fail,
That is hope.
To be hopeless
Becomes a form of villainy,
Whether you join the bad guys or not.
At the very least,
Hopelessness
Stops right action at its source,
Stops your light from shining in the darkness,
Stops your voice from sounding clear in the cacophony.
But to act on hope,
To act as if your actions matter,
To act as if our voices will be heard,
To shine your light and trust that it will
Not only pierce the darkness
But inspire other lights,
Is to have lived well
No matter how things turn out.
Hopeless people join in
And build Orthanc
And Death Stars
And try to preserve their own little patch of freedom
At the expense of others.
Hope scrambles across the shattered landscape near
Mount Doom
Or flies a desperate trip down
A Death Star trench
Or simply walks across a bridge
They said not to cross.
For of course, these stories
Are not just found in fictional epics.
To live in hope isn't to think
Things will turn out right,
But to believe that standing for
The Good
Is always worth it in the end.